Kimi K3.1 Pro vs Qwen4-Max-Preview

Kimi K3.1 Pro

The settled sphere, separate airborne black paint and crimson-before-cyan interaction are supported, with a modest crimson travel overshoot. A shared downward framing displacement remains after accounting for the square canvas. The principal limitation is the reflection system: sparse sphere copies and generic curved bands omit most of the ordered mirror-room structure. Materials receive a small upward revision because bounded bright images and dark bands visibly establish some polish, while soft shading and bulky paint remain separate weaknesses.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

The main placement, compact airborne black and contrasting cyan/crimson interaction states are largely supported. Recognizable first mirror images earn substantial local credit despite modest silhouette and overlap errors. Most of the defining mirror system remains missing, especially nested spherical imagery, outer chains and repeated emitter mapping. Crimson also extends slightly too far down the facing surface.

Kimi K3.1 Pro

The transformed reflection, attentive pose and constellation anatomy clearly communicate introspection. Purposeful fine details enrich a coherent composition. Tubular limbs, crowded lower-body overlaps, shallow depth and limited cast lighting keep the overall execution within the competent range.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

A coherent celestial character with readable costume layers, controlled ornament and coordinated luminous accents. Simplified joints, shallow frontal space and limited material modeling constrain construction and drawing complexity. The raised palm's orientation remains only partially demonstrated.

Kimi K3.1 Pro

An imagined creature encounters its reflection. The scene tests original character design, visual self-interpretation and the relationship between a subject and its reflected image.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

A floating capybara in ornate robes tests character anatomy, layered fabric and the placement of surrounding luminous forms.

Kimi K3.1 Pro

A coherent, recognizable interpretation with controlled color and readable landscape layers. Replication is limited by the frontal seated construction, elongated facial proportions and oversized, weakly articulated hands. Smooth shading supplies some volume but little of the reference's subtle expression, fabric structure or atmospheric transitions.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

A coherent, recognizable interpretation with developed facial shading and purposeful portrait details. The frontal, nearly symmetric body, inflated sleeves and unresolved hand articulation substantially limit replication and construction. Layered scenery supplies basic depth, while uniformly smooth surfaces and schematic folds constrain material character and drawing complexity.

Kimi K3.1 Pro

A coherent, playful beach illustration with readable animals, an organized composition and an aligned sunset reflection. Connected silhouettes, sand texture and atmospheric effects demonstrate controlled execution. Simplified joints, flattened foreground viewpoints and inconsistent shadows limit anatomical and spatial credibility.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

A coherent sunset illustration with sweeping palms, recognizable wildlife and varied, readable beach details. Atmospheric layering and controlled contours strengthen its character. Basic animal anatomy, overhead-looking foreground creatures and schematic cast shadows limit construction and physical depth.

Kimi K3.1 Pro

This benchmark has not been assessed yet.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

This benchmark has not been assessed yet.

Kimi K3.1 Pro

The additional comparisons support retaining the assessment. Readable steering, shaped animal contours and purposeful details coexist with simplified joints, a frontal passenger whose seated weight is weakly conveyed, and limited physical lighting. The angled craft establishes more depth than the riding pose resolves.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

An expressive cartoon with purposeful accessory detail, readable steering and directional spray. The aligned sunset reflection adds physical coherence. Simplified joints and the frontal raccoon's uncertain seated support continue to limit anatomy, perspective and integrity.

Kimi K3.1 Pro

A characterful coastal illustration with controlled contours and varied feather, accessory and bicycle detail. Layered scenery and subtle shading enrich the presentation. Soft leg articulation, unresolved riding contacts, shallow depth and generalized lighting limit physical precision.

Qwen4-Max-Preview

A detailed coastal illustration with readable seated support, steering and pedal contacts. Continuous anatomy, coherent bicycle construction and purposeful small features support its expressive composition. Simplified limb articulation, modest perspective depth and weakly directional ground shadows limit physical conviction.